Methodology · v1.0 · published 2026-11-19
How we score an agency.
A score is a weighted mean of seven criteria, each scored 0–100. Evidence must be public and linkable. Two criteria are measured by our own systems. The rules are the same for every agency, including the one that operates this site.
01 Proof of results — 25%
Can they show work that moved rankings, traffic or revenue?
Their own Google position for “SEO agency/company <city>”: top 3 = 60 points, top 10 = 45, top 20 = 30, top 50 = 15. Plus case studies with measurable results: 15 points each with a named client, 6 without (max 40).
Measured automatically, monthly, from servers in several regions. Raw results are stored and shown on each agency page.
02 Client reviews — 20%
What do clients say, across independent platforms?
Google rating and review count: √(rating above 3.5, scaled) × log(review count, 200 = full marks). Reviews on other independent platforms are added once verified.
Measured automatically, monthly, from servers in several regions. Raw results are stored and shown on each agency page.
03 Own-site technical quality — 15%
Does their own website practise what they sell?
Core Web Vitals from Google’s real-user data where available (LCP, INP, CLS: 15 points each), HTTPS 10, indexable homepage 15, organisation structured data 15, XML sitemap 15.
Measured automatically, monthly, from servers in several regions. Raw results are stored and shown on each agency page.
04 Transparency — 15%
Do you know who you are hiring and what it costs?
Published pricing 40, named team 25, address 20, contact page 15.
05 Demonstrated expertise — 10%
Do practitioners publish, teach or speak under their own names?
Publishes articles 30, signed by named practitioners 40, talks, research or awards cited 30.
06 Longevity — 10%
Have they been around long enough to be accountable?
7 points per year since the earlier of founding year and domain registration (max 100).
Measured automatically, monthly, from servers in several regions. Raw results are stored and shown on each agency page.
07 Specialisation — 5%
Are they clearly good at something specific?
One stated speciality 100, two 85, three 65, generalist 40.
Preliminary scores
Every new profile starts as a preliminary score built only from what we can observe: the agency's Google position for its own city, its Google reviews, a technical audit of its website and what that website publishes about results, pricing and team. Text on websites is read by a language model and every extracted claim links back to the page it came from. When an agency or our editors verify further evidence, the label is removed.
What we never do
We do not sell positions, accept payment for scores or publish anonymous reviews. Paid verification only speeds up checking an agency's evidence; a verified agency with weak evidence still scores low.
Corrections
Any agency can submit new evidence or dispute an item. Accepted changes are re-scored within seven days and recorded in the agency's score history.
Changelog
v1.0 — 2026-11-19. First public version.